Amy Engelhardt and Bob Malone

Two Bobs: No Waiting

The Duplex
New York, NY
As Amy Engelhardt was ending her set at The Duplex (the first half of a show she was sharing with Bob Malone), a cabaret performer sitting next to me grabbed my pen and scribbled on my notepad, “She’s amazing!,” with a very large exclamation point for emphasis. She wasn’t influencing my review because I had already come to that conclusion a few songs before. Later, as Malone was banging out yet another awesome piano riff during his set, I leaned over to my cabaret friend and whispered, “This guy’s terrific,” with a very large exclamation point in my voice.

Based on the audience reaction, we weren’t alone in our effusive assessments. Two Bobs: No Waiting was definitely worth waiting for. (Engelhardt is a “Bob” by virtue of her 13 years—which recently ended—as the female member of the offbeat, primarily a cappella group, The Bobs.) It’s not often you get a two-shows-for-the-price-of-one bargain in a cabaret venue, but that’s essentially what the audience had lucked into with Engelhardt and Malone’s immensely satisfying performances, made up mostly of original compositions that define their individual musical personalities. And with Malone playing keyboard for his long-time friend’s set, she teasing him from offstage during his set, and the duo coming together for a joint encore (on a song they wrote for Meatloaf in 2002, but was never recorded), the show felt structurally seamless.

The two performers grew up in the same New Jersey town and traveled in some of the same L.A. music scene circles for years, but had never met until 1999 when Malone opened for The Bobs at a show in Santa Cruz. A few years later, he played the George Gershwin piano rolls for The Bobs’ phenomenal vocalese version of “Rhapsody in Blue.” Since then, both have produced CDs of their original songs (Malone played keyboards and helped produce Engelhardt’s 2008 CD, Not Gonna Be Pretty; she has sung backup vocals on some of his discs), he has become the keyboard player for John Fogerty’s band, and she has recently moved to New York and was promptly honored by MAC with a 2011 Dottie Burman Songwriting Award.

After hearing a chunk of Engelhardt’s songbook at The Duplex, it’s understandable why she gets kudos for her songwriting. She brings a comedienne’s sensibility to her lyrics (as well as to her singing and performing), which can be poignant, provocative and playful all in the same song, as with the comic ballad, “Springtime in Syracuse” (one of the three songs submitted for the Burman Award): “Springtime in Syracuse/Annoying people reproduce/In Syracuse, 20 years ago you came/I’m still tearing, and I’m hearing your name.”

Another song that helped Engelhardt earn the award is already being covered by cabaret singers, the hilariously blasphemous Virgin Mary soliloquy, “How Did This Thing Get in Me?,” featuring references to what Joseph might be doing with his sheep, and this play-by-play of the Virgin Birth: “Back at the stable now I’m starting to push/The cattle are lowing and there’s hay in my tush/They bring me frankincense and gold and some myrrh/But a good ol’ epidural’s what I’d really prefer.”

Since many of Engelhardt’s songs are quirky and character-driven, her elastic, three-octave, mezzo soprano can almost get lost in the shuffle. But she can go deep on the bitter mother-daughter relationship song “Like Me,” girlishly light on the unrequited love ballad “Cheese Denied,” optimistic on “Once of Hope,” and even sultry on a cover of the bluesy “Naughty Number Nine” (Bob Dorough), from the old TV show Schoolhouse Rock. The latter featured terrific work from Malone and band mates Ritt Henn (electric bass) and Rick Zucker (drums), both of whom have often played with Malone on the road.

Malone and the band opened his set with the rocking, bounce-in-your-seat instrumental “Chinese Algebra,” and it was all uphill from there. When you hear Malone’s pulsating keyboard style combined with his coarse, bluesy vocals, you can imagine him performing the songs on the recent Elton John/Leon Russell CD The Union all by himself. In fact, on his one cover in the show, The Band’s “Up on Cripple Creek” (Robbie Robertson), Malone’s piano sound was vintage Elton. But the musical and vocal similarities didn’t stop there. He was Randy Newman-esque on the cheeky “I Know He’s Your Husband (But He Don’t Know That I’m Your Man),” channeled Joe Cocker on the painfully introspective “No One Can Hurt You (Like Me),” and sounded like Bob Seger on the rocker “Home to Me.”

Just when you thought he couldn’t expend any more energy, Malone raised the bar, leading the band on the driving “Looking for the Blues” and the swinging blues number “Ain’t What You Know,” both of which featured fantastic up-off-the-bench piano riffing.

I know what I know. Amy Engelhardt and Bob Malone were revelations.

Stephen Hanks
Cabaret Scenes
January 27, 2012
www.cabaretscenes.org